Pretty fun site. Too bad you can't pick the 97-98 Crusaders ;)
http://www.whatifsports.com/ncaab/default.asp#top (http://www.whatifsports.com/ncaab/default.asp#top)
If it had happened at the ARC:
Final - 11/27/2012 1st 2nd Total
11-12 Baylor 27 34 61
11-12 Valparaiso 31 40 71
Scott would have been buying dinner.
Replay of last NCAA appearance:
03-04 Valparaiso 36 38 74
03-04 Gonzaga 38 45 83
A little more exciting ;)
AAARGH
Final - 1st 2nd Total
11-12 Valparaiso 42 33 75
11-12 Miami (FL) 41 35 76